Who was on the Bristol Merchant in 1685?

When writing the book Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh, the research that created the biggest headache was in determining who arrived in America, who stayed, who died, and who returned to Ireland.

We know the Farmar family embarked on the Bristol Merchant which may have left Liverpool on 11 August 1685, arrived into County of Cork, Ireland for more passengers, and then arrived into Pennsylvania on 10 November 1685.

70 passengers and their belongings were on the Bristol Merchant, similar to this ship pictured above

 

The first item to discern was… who made the voyage? Several resources have a different account of the passenger list, which has been compiled below.[1]

Major Jasper Farmar (b, c, d, e, f, g, h)
Mary Farmar, wife of Major Jasper Farmar (a, b, c, d, e, f, g, h)
Edward Farmar, son of Major Jasper (a, b, c, d, e, f, g)
Richard Farmar, son of Major Jasper (b, g)
Sarah Farmar, daughter of Major Jasper (a, b, c, d, e, f, g)
John Farmar, son of Major Jasper (a, c, e, f, g)
Robert Farmar, son of Major Jasper (a, b, d, e, f, g)
Catharine Farmar, daughter of Major Jasper (a, b, d, e, f, g)
Charles Farmar, son of Major Jasper (a, b, c, d, e, f, g)

Jasper Farmar, Jr., son of Major Jasper (a, b, c, d, e, f, g)
Catharine Farmar, wife of Jasper Jr. (a, c, d, e, f)
Thomas Farmar, son of Jasper Jr. (a, c, d, e, f)
Elizabeth Farmar, daughter of Jasper Jr. (a, c, d, e, f)
Katherine Farmar, daughter of Jasper Jr. (c, d, e, f)

Edward Batsford, step-son of Major Jasper (a, c, d)

About twenty [b] artisans and Servants, all from Ireland [a]:
Joanna Daly, also “Joan Daly” and “Joane Daly” (a, c, e, f)
Philip Mayow (a, c, e, f)
Helen Mayow, wife of Philip Mayow (a, c, e, f)
John Mayow (a, c, e, f)
John Whitlow, also “Whitloe” (a, c, e, f)
Nicholas Whitlow, also “Whitloe” (a, c, e, f)
Thomas Young, also “Younge” (a, c, e, f)
___ Young, wife of Thomas Young (a, c, e, f)
William Winter (a, c, e, f)
George Fisher (a, c, e, f)
Arthur Smithy, also “Smith” (a, c, e, f)
Thomas Alferry (a, c, e, f)
Henry Wells (a, c, e, f)
Robert Wilkinson, also “Wilkison” (a, c, e, f)
Elizabeth Mayow (a, c, e, f)
Martha Mayow (a, c, e, f)
Albert Dawson (c)
Sarah Burke, possibly also “Sara Binke” (a, c, e, f)
Sheele Oceven, possibly also “Thebe Orevan” and “Shebe Orevan” (a, c, e, f)
Andrew Walbridge (a, c, e, f)

Thomas Webb (e, f, h)
Daniel Webb, son of Thomas Webb (e, f, h)

Servants of Thomas Webb:
John Beltshire (e, f)
John Robinson (e, f)
Richard Ford (e, f)
James Banbury (e, f)
Thomas Case (e, f)
Henry Ford (e, f)
John Fox (e, f)
Derby Haley (e, f)
Joseph Case (e, f)
Thomas Burke (e, f)
John Garrett, also “Garrell” (e, f)
John Mehone (e, f)
David Quinn (e, f)
Mary Widdam (e, f)
Prudence Stuart (e, f)
Katherine Robinson (e, f)
Richard Muske (e, f)

Nicholas Scull, Major Jasper’s nephew through Jasper’s sister Alice (a, e, f, h)

Servants of Nicholas Scull:
Samuel Hall (a, e, f)
Cornelius Davye (a, e, f)
George Gooding (a, e, f)
Miles Morin (a, e, f)
Daniel Morin (a, e, f)
John Ward (a, e, f)
Mary Cantwell, also “Cantrell” (a, e, f)

Thomas Carter, Sr. (e, f)
Frances Carter, wife of Thomas Carter Sr. (e, f)
Thomas Carter, Jr., son of Thomas Carter Sr. (e, f)
Henry Carter, son of Thomas Carter Sr. (e, f)
John Carter, son of Thomas Carter Sr. (e, f)
Ann Carter, daughter of Thomas Carter Sr. (e, f)

Jonathon Thatcher (e, f)

Ann Besor, from Bristol, bound for Virginia.[2]

 

The second hurdle was to determine whether Major Jasper Farmar died prior to the voyage, died en route, or died after arriving into Philadelphia.

Dies before the voyage? “When all arrangements had been made for the voyage Major Farmar died, when his widow, Mary and children… embarked on the ship Bristol Merchant, John Stephens, master, and arrived at Philadelphia November 10, 1685…”[3] If Major Jasper dies before the voyage, why is his name on the manifest list?

Dies before he arrives? “Major Farmar did not live to see his colony established as his death occurred just as the vessel came to port in Philadelphia…”[4] and “Some records state that Major Jaspar and his son Jaspar, Jr. both died on the voyage…”[5]

Dies after arriving? “Major Farmar arrived at Philadelphia, September 10, 1685, on board the Bristol Merchant, Captain John Stevens commander, with his family…”[6]

It is generally accepted, based on dates of Major Jasper Farmar’s will and the names on the manifest, that members of the family died en route and were buried at sea.

 

The third hurdle was determining the children referenced in the will of Major Jasper Farmar’s wife, Madame Farmar, dated 31 October 1686:

“In the name of God, Amen. I, Mary Farmar, widdow and relict of Major Jasper Farmar of Ireland, being weak in health but in perfect memory, blessed by God, doe make this my last Will and Testament in manner and forme followeing, that is to say, Imprimis, I give and bequeath my Soule into the hand of my God my Creator who give it me, and who alone is able to keepe it, and my body to be buried with or neare my children in this towne of Philadelphia…”[7]

Which of the children are buried in Philadelphia who preceded Madame Farmar in death? John Farmar witnessed the will which names Edward Farmar, Edward Batsford, Sarah Farmar, and Katherine (Batsford) Farmar (the widowed wife of Jasper Jr.); therefore, they all survived Madame Farmar. Administration on the estate of Madame Farmar’s other son, William Batsford, states he “died at sea without a Will coming from Ireland to this Province in the eighth month 1684” and was granted “in the second month (April) 1687” to “Edward Batsford, his brother.” It is inferred that William died during his trip in October 1684 on a separate ship as his name does not appear on the manifest of the Bristol Merchant. (reference Cook, “Farmar of Ardevalaine,” p.90.)

Cook states that “[Katherine, Robert, and Charles] were possibly deceased by 31 October 1686, the date of the will of Mary Farmar…”[8] Some accounts state that Katherine Farmar, the daughter of Major Jasper Farmar and Mary Gamble, died and was buried at sea with her father and her brother Jasper Jr. That no records exist for Katherine, Robert, and Charles, after 1685, it is accepted that they are the children referenced in Madame Farmar’s will.

 

The next hurdle was determining who remained in Pennsylvania. John Farmar is presumed to have returned to England where he married Mary Hayles in 1686 and had a son, John.

The last obstacle was determining if Richard Farmar had joined his family across the Atlantic, and if he did, whether he remained in Pennsylvania. Any evidence is circumstantial, but Richard may not have been on the Bristol Merchant. Only two cited resources have Richard making the voyage, whereas one resource states “[Major Jasper] also settled any financial obligations he may have felt necessary with his two grown sons, Richard and Samuel, who had elected not to make the voyage to America…”[9]

That Richard remains in Ireland is further supported by the last will and testament of Major Jasper Farmar dated 25 September 1685, with Richard’s inclusion on the same line as Samuel Farmar and Mary (Farmar) Webber (who also did not make the voyage).

“In the name of God, Amen. I, Major Jasper Farmer being weak in health but in perfect memory blessed be God doe make this my last Will and testament in manner and forme following that is to say, Imprimus. I give and bequeath my Soule into the hands of Almighty God that gave it and my body to be buryed wherever it shall please the Lord I dye… Item, I give and bequeath unto my sonns Richard Farmer and Samuel Farmer and my daughter Webber in Ireland tenn shillings a peece to bye them mourning rings, and to my sonn Jasper Farmer and daughter Web tenn shillings a peece to buy them rings…”[10]

Deposition: “Major Jasper Farmer to his son Richard Farmer. Be it remembered that Samuel Hunt of Philadelphia in the province of Pensilvania, being legally attested before me Humphrey Morrey, one of the justices of the peace of the County of Philadelphia, Deposeth and saith as followeth, that is to say. That he this Deponent, about the tenth day of September which was in the year 1685, saw a certain Deed from Major Jasper Farmer to Richard Farmer, of that date, sealed and executed by the said Major Farmar unto the said Richard Farmar for a certain ferme purchased by the said Major from one Sir Boyle Maynard, and upon delivery thereof this Deponent heard the said Major demand of Richard Farmar whether he was satisfied and whether he owed him anything. Whereunto the said Richard answered that the said Major owed him nothing upon any account whatever, or words to that effect. And this Deponent further saith that he, this Deponent, was desired by Major Jasper Farmar, since deceased to draw his the said Jasper’s last Will and Testament, dated the twenty fifth day of September 1685, which Will this Deponent drew according to his directions, and which said Will and Testament he the said Major Jasper Farmar, being of sound and perfect memory, at the same time did seal and execute and publish in this Deponent’s and Edward Farmar’s presence, who have subscribed their names as witnesses thereunto. In witness whereof the said Deponent hath hereunto set his hand the 8th day of the 5th month July 1687. (signed) Saml Hunt. Attested by and before me, the day and year aforesaid Humphrey Morrey.”[11]

The disposition of Samuel Hunt attests that on 10 September 1685, he personally saw Major Jasper and his son Richard agree to the settlement of the farm, and witnessed Major Jasper write his will on 25 September 1685. Samuel Hunt isn’t listed on the Bristol Merchant manifest,[12] and Samuel Farmar’s signature on the back of the will further proves the document was written before the family set sail, but still does not prove Richard stayed in Ireland.

“By deed of 23 April 1685, Richard Farmer of Arderrack, Co. Corke, Ireland, gent., conveyed to Thomas Webb of Racannon, Co. Limerick, gent., for £144,4 sterling money of England, his one-quarter part of 5,000 acres granted by patent and which by mutual consent of the patentees is to be divided by the Surveyor General resident in Pennsylvania, together with his share of such goods and servants as were carried over there…”[13]

“…That said Richard Farmer assigned unto said Thomas Webb for £144, 4, sterling money of England all his right and title in his said fourth part of the said 5,000 acres and his property of such goods and servants as were carried over by the said Jasper Farmer, Jr. when the Patent was granted…” [14]

Although most accounts chronologically state that Richard “soon” or “shortly after” sells his quarter share of the land during the probate of his father’s will, the date of the land deed implies that four months before the family departs for Pennsylvania, Richard deeded his share of the 5,000 acres along with his belongings already in America which arrived on his brother’s trip in 1682, to his brother-in-law Thomas Webb. If so, why would Richard make the voyage and leave behind his wife and four children under the age of nine?

[The other big question:  Why did Thomas Webb sell his land to Madame Farmar?]

If Richard had arrived in America, he soon returned to Ireland based on a deed from 3 August 1687:

“John Barnes of Bristol Township, Philadelphia County conveyed to Edward Batsford of the town of Philadelphia, yeoman, for £225 a tract of 500 acres on Tacony Creek in Bristol Twp., subject to a mortgage to secure three bills of exchange for £140 drawn on Edward Boyle of Co. Cork, Ireland, Esq., reciting that “Whereas Mistris Catherine Farmer, relict and executrix of the deceased Jasper Farmer (Jr.) late of the Co. of Cork in the said Kingdom of Ireland, Gent., did also this day draw three bills of exchange containing 50 Pounds upon Richard Farmer of the Co. of Tipperary in the said Kingdom of Ireland, Gent., payable in three score days sight thereof unto the said Richard Barnes or his order,” the £190 money of England, being in current silver money of the said Province, £237,10.”[15]

Burke’s Landed Gentry states that Richard “was obliged to leave Ireland in 1689, and retired with his family to Taunton Deane, in Somersetshire. He returned to Ireland in 1691…”[16] His will is dated 01 January 1690 and was proved 28 March 1691, naming wife Elizabeth (daughter of Robert Phaire of Grange, County Cork), and children:  Jasper, Robert, John and Elizabeth.[17]

It is presumed that the following is simply stating that Richard has died by 1767, as Edward was the last surviving son of Major Jasper, as it pertains to the ownership of the original 5,000 acres.

“At a Special Meeting at the Governors on Monday the 19th of October 1767: Peter Robeson agt Jno. Morris, On Caveat… Jasper the Son dyed and left his Share of the said Land to his wife Catharine who afterwards married one Billup. Richard also dyed Edward only survived…”[18]

 

Philip Farmer is the author and publisher of “Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh,” a 500-page, 155-year biographical history of the Farmer family’s immigration from Ireland into Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Virginia, Tennessee, and Harlan County, Kentucky.

Very well written and researched…”
Ms. L. King

I love your work… Very interesting!
Ms. B. H. Baker

click to learn more

[1] Sources:

a. Bean, Theodore W. History of Montgomery County, Pennsylvania (1884), p.1139.

b. Mann, Charles S. “Fort Washington Historic Environs.” Historical Sketches: A Collection of Papers Prepared for the Historical Society of Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, vol. 2 (1900), p.203.

c. Billopp, Charles Farmar. A History of Thomas and Anne Billopp Farmar, And Some of Their Descendants in America (1907), p.11-12.

d. Jordan, John W., Edgar Moore Green, & George T. Ettinger. Historic Homes and Institutions and Genealogical and Personal Memoirs of The Lehigh Valley, Pennsylvania, vol. 1 (1905), p.43.

e. Cook, Lewis D. “Farmar of Ardevalaine, County Tipperary, Ireland and of Whitemarsh, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania.” The Pennsylvania Genealogical Magazine, vol. 21, no. 2 (1959), p.90-91. Original citation “A Partial List of the Families Who Arrived at Philadelphia Between 1682 and 1687,” Philadelphia Magazine of History and Biography, vol. 8 (1884), p.336.

f. Ralston, Harold A. “Ship Passenger Lists, Scot and Irish.” Our Ralston and Belden Family Histories. 2007-2017. Retrieved 24 September 2018:
http://www.ralstongenealogy.com/sislist.htm#forty8

g. Yeakle, William A. “Whitemarsh.” Historical Sketches. A Collection of Papers Prepared for the Historical Society of Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, vol. 1 (1895), p.18-19.

h. Baker, Jr., C.A. “Chapter 21, My Pennsylvania Ancestors, Part 1.” Baker Family Tree. 16 January 2009. Retrieved 15 March 2018:
http://bakerfamilytree.blogspot.com/2009/01/

“In late August of 1685, Jasper and Mary Farmar, six of their children including three children from his wife’s first marriage, plus his son Jasper and his wife and their three children, and his daughter (name unknown) and her husband, Thomas Webb, and their son, and at least twenty of their servants and their children boarded the ship “Bristol Merchant” in Ireland bound for Philadelphia. Also on board was Nicholas Scull, son of Jasper’s sister Alice, and his seven servants…”

[2] “Indentured Servants Basic Search Results” Virtual Jamestown. Retrieved 24 September 2018:
http://www.virtualjamestown.org/indentures/search_indentures.cgi?start_page=522&search_type=basic&db=bristol_ind&servant_ln=%

[3] Bean, History of Montgomery County, Pennsylvania (1884), p.1139.

[4] Mann, “Fort Washington Historic Environs,” p.204.

[5] Billopp, A History of Thomas and Anne Billopp Farmar, p.12.

[6] Mann, “Fort Washington Historic Environs,” p.203. The date of 10 September 1685 is a misinterpretation of the Julian and Gregorian calendars.

[7] “Colonial Estates – Philadelphia, PA & Bucks County, PA,” Hobbs and Phillips Family Genealogy. Retrieved 29 April 2018:
http://www.angelfire.com/ga/hobbsphillips/colonialestates.html
;
Cook, “Farmar of Ardevalaine,” p.93.

[8] Cook, “Farmar of Ardevalaine,” p.90-91.

[9] Baker, “Chapter 21, My Pennsylvania Ancestors, Part 1.” Note that Samuel will eventually immigrate to Virginia in March 1689.

[10] Cook, “Farmar of Ardevalaine,” p.93-94.

[11] Cook, “Farmar of Ardevalaine,” p.92. Recorded 9th day of 5th month 1687 in Philadelphia Letters of Attorney Book D-2-4, 166, now in Bureau of Land Records, Department of Internal Affairs, Harrisburg.

[12] “Samuel Hunt” is not on the manifest, but “Samuel Hall” is. Is it possible that Samuel Hunt was on the Bristol Merchant and that the surname is incorrect due to mistranslation?

[13] Cook, “Farmar of Ardevalaine,”, p.91. Recorded 1st day 12th month 1685 in Deed Book E-l-5, p.156.

[14] Cook, “Farmar of Ardevalaine,” p.91-92. Acknowledged in Open Court 3rd day 12th month 1685 and recorded 10th day of 12th month 1685 in Deed Book E-l-5, p.174.

[15] Cook, “Farmar of Ardevalaine,” p.90. Recorded in Philadelphia Deed Book E-l-5, 542.

[16] Burke, Sir John Bernard. A Genealogical and Heraldic Dictionary of the Landed Gentry of Great Britain and Ireland (1858), p.368.

[17] Cook, “Farmar of Ardevalaine,” p.99.

[18] Cook, “Farmar of Ardevalaine,” p.92.

Genealogy and… Star Trek?

When doing your family genealogy, you might find that you’re related to someone famous… such is the case in my family tree.

When doing your family genealogy, you might find that you’re related to someone famous… either a professional athlete, or historical figure, or actor. You may have met someone who proudly exclaims that they’re related to George Washington, or they’re a direct descendant of royalty.

Today’s story starts all the way back to the 1600’s. Major Jasper Farmar married first Mary Gamble and they had a son, Jasper Farmar Jr. When Mary died, Major Jasper married the widow Mary Batsford in 1671. She brought into the marriage her three children William, Edward, and Katherine Batsford. Major Jasper and Mary had a daughter Sarah, and had a son Edward Farmar born in 1672.

Jasper Farmar Jr. married his step-sister Katherine Batsford on or about 06 July 1674. Together, they had a son, Thomas Farmar born in 1674. When Jasper Jr. died at sea on his second voyage to Pennsylvania in 1685, the Widow Katherine remarried Captain Christopher Billopp. Billopp had two daughters from a prior marriage, Anne and Mary. Katherine’s son Thomas married his step-sister Anne in 1703. Mary married twice; once to Reverend Brooke, who was lost at sea en route to England in 1707, and second to Reverend William Skinner of Perth Amboy.

Katherine died before April 1700. When Captain Christopher Billopp wrote his will on 25 April 1724, he devised his Indians Land plantation in New Brunswick, Middlesex County, New Jersey to his daughter Anne (Billopp) Farmar. The will also devised his Bentley Manor (New Jersey) to his daughter Mary (Billopp) Skinner of Perth Amboy during her life only. However, if Mary should pass away with no sons, then the property would pass to Anne (Billopp) Farmar’s second son, Christopher, or to his surviving brothers in succession, so long as they adopt the surname Billopp. Mary had no children when she died in 1725. Thomas and Anne’s son Christopher had died, so Thomas Farmar, Jr. qualified as heir and, accepting the terms of his grandfather’s will, changed his surname from Farmar to Billopp.

By tracing Jasper Jr.’s branch of the family tree, you find Jane Waddington Wyatt, who many may know as the actress in the 1950’s sitcom Father Knows Best and several motion pictures.

If you’re a big Star Trek fan, you may know her as Amanda Grayson, the mother of Spock, who first appeared in the episode Journey to Babel (1967) and in Star Trek IV:  The Voyage Home (1986).

“When you go back in time to save some whales, can you grab some missing information for the family tree?”

Jane would be my ninth cousin, as we share the same 8th great grandfather, Major Jasper Farmar, who died 333 years ago while moving his family to America.

click to enlarge

And in another 212 years on 06 January 2230, Spock will be born.

“We’re related to the Farmer’s? Seems logical.”

Live long and prosper.

Philip Farmer is the author and publisher of “Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh,” a 500-page, 155-year biographical history of the Farmer family’s immigration from Ireland into Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Virginia, Tennessee, and Harlan County, Kentucky.

Very well written and researched…”
Ms. L. King

I love your work… Very interesting!
Ms. B. H. Baker

click to learn more

William Penn and the Farmar’s

As large landowners in southeast County Cork, Ireland, the Penn’s and the Farmar’s knew each other and continued their relationship into early 1700 Pennsylvania. The following is excerpted from the book Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh.

Musketeers at the Battle of Stratton, 16 May 1643. This battle during the English Civil War (1642-1651) shows an example of how the men under Major Jasper Farmar’s command would appear.

As early as 1677, William Penn was part of a group purchasing land in the western side of present New Jersey. Once the land was acquired, they immediately encouraged its settlement, particularly among English Quakers. Surprisingly, British Parliament and King Charles II granted Penn a charter in March 1681 as the sole proprietor of land that would become Pennsylvania. Historians have suggested that the British government, by granting the land to Penn, had hoped the troublesome Quakers would leave England. Some historians suggest that it was part of a debt repayment to his father Sir William Penn. Others suggest that, through his relationship with the Duke of York, it ensured James a friendly neighbor who was concurrently the proprietor of New York immediately to the north of “Penn’s Land.”

To build his new province, William began negotiating and purchasing tracts of land from the local Indians. Penn then immediately began an active promotion throughout Europe to market and resell his property. To attract settlers in large numbers to his new province, William wrote a glowing prospectus in various languages that promised religious freedom as well as other advantages about the new land in America. Within six months he had parceled out 300,000 acres to over 250 prospective sellers, mostly rich London Quakers. Eventually he attracted other persecuted minorities including Huguenots, Mennonites, Anabaptists, Catholics, Lutherans, and Jews from England, France, Holland, Germany, Finland, Wales, and Ireland.

One of his first customers was Major Jasper Farmar. Major Jasper had lived for many years upon his estate in Garranekinnefeake, or “Garron Kenny Fange” Parish, village of Midleton, County of Cork, Ireland. His brother, John Farmar, resided on his estate in the neighboring village of Youghal. William Penn’s father had been granted lands in County Cork, Ireland for his services during the English Civil War. With Sir Penn’s failing health, William was sent to manage the estate in 1666, and when Sir Penn died in 1670, young William, then twenty-six years old, inherited “Penn’s Castle” – over 5,000 acres across eight square miles of land near the present village of Shanagarry. The villages of Midleton, Youghal, and Shanagarry neighbor each other, and as large landowners in southeast County Cork, the Penn’s and Farmar’s knew each other.

As early as 29th day 10th month 1669, Penn writes in his diary…

“[29th day 10th month 1669] Major fformer & J.Bolese came to me. I had advise from F. din’d and sup’d at sh. I have perus’d Part of ye Jusu. Book.”[1]

[22nd day 11th month 1669] I mett Ger. ff’tz Ger’ld about ye windmill, we concluded on 44lb per An’o & what It shall be adjudg’d more worth by Farmer, & Gale. I paying quitrent.

[10th day 12th month 1669] we left youghall, & w. H. his daughter, R.C. & P.C. & ye rest of us Came to M. ffarmers, & thence to shangary, where we lay being Civilly treated.

[21st day 11 month 1669] I went & Coll Wallis to Coll. Phairs, about ye reference the land was returned 4s 3ds per acre. I paying quitrent. I abated 6d per Acre, & h’t was 3s 9d p Acre. we so agreed on all sides. He before C.Phair Beul ffarmer, Wallis &c: gave vp Inchs y’e hous not to touch & arrears of rent to pay. so we return’d home to C.Phairs ser’t 1s.

[1st day 12th month 1669]. M. ffarmer & M. woodly Came to C. Ceuls I. spoak to them. from thence we Went to Corke. J. Boles being with us. we meet with Coll. Phair. His wife. & seuerall of his ffamely.”[2]

Coincidentally, the Puritan immigration into America’s provinces came to an abrupt halt when Sir Oliver Cromwell came to power, since the primary reason to flee England, religious freedom, was removed. In an ironic twist of fate for a Royalist supporter, the restoration of the monarchy with Charles II in 1661 restored the “need” for immigration, and presumably from his acquaintance and conversations with Penn, provides Major Jasper with the seeds of thought to immigrate to Pennsylvania. Additionally, years earlier his great grandfather, George Fermor, had purchased shares in the Second Virginia Company Charter which funded the Jamestown, Virginia settlement as early as 1609 in which Major Jasper’s distant cousin, Thomas Farmer, had been living since 1616, although not much had been heard from him since 1632.[3]

Penn undoubtedly described Pennsylvania as being more beautiful and fertile than Ireland, with temperate weather, friendly Indians, plenty of wild game, and religious freedom – all overseen by a democratic government operating under a constitution where power was derived from the people.

Major Jasper, dissatisfied with the turbulent political and financial condition of affairs by which he was surrounded, and through his friendship with Penn, was led to embark for a new life by taking up a “Plantation” in the new Province of Pennsylvania. But at the age of seventy-two, with a wife in her late forties, and at least seven children still living at home, it was a personal investment fraught with doubt. One has to wonder the emotional debate and discussions between Major Jasper, Mary, and their children.

In 1682, Major Jasper sent his 29-year-old son, Jasper Farmar, Jr., to make a voyage of investigation in “Penn’s Land.” Pleased at what he discovered, Jasper Jr., on behalf of himself, his father Major Jasper, and his brother Richard, took up, in two tracts, five thousand acres of land by a proprietary patent dated 31 January 1683.

“L. S.: William Penn, Proprietary and Governor of Pennsylvania and the Territories thereunto belonging. At the request of Jaspar Farmar, Junior, in the behalf of his father, Major Jaspar Farmar, his brother Richard and himself, that I would grant him to take up 5,000 acres of land, being of the lands by the Indians called Umbilicamence, fronting At one end upon the River Schuylkill. These are to will and require thee forthwith to survey or cause to be surveyed unto him the said five thousand acres in the aforementioned place where not already taken up, according to the method of townships appointed by me, and make return thereof unto my Secretary’s office. Given at Philadelphia the 3lst of the l0th month, 1683.
Wm. Penn.
For Thomas Holmes, Surveyor-General.”[4]

Every obligation Major Jasper had with his family who wished to remain in Ireland, including his son Samuel, had been settled in preparation for the trip. His oldest daughter Elizabeth had died in 1682, and his daughter Mary Webber, who did not make the trip, had married and received from her father a large dowry. In late August 1685, Major Jasper’s family, as well as the family of his son Jasper Jr., the family of his daughter Katherine Webb, and the servants of all three families, boarded the ship Bristol Merchant commanded by Captain John Stephens. By doing so, Major Jasper Farmar made a full life-changing decision backed by a strong financial commitment. The trip was extremely expensive. Not only were there the costs of the passage for all of his family and their servants, but there was also the added expense to ship all of the family belongings, including their furniture.

The weakness and loss of weight for the passengers aboard the Bristol Merchant left them vulnerable to diseases, and at the age of seventy-five, Major Jasper Farmar was especially vulnerable. Somewhere in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean, Mary Farmar buried her husband Major Jasper, her stepson Jasper Jr., her stepdaughter Katherine, and perhaps several others whose names have been lost in history. After a ten-week voyage across the Atlantic Ocean, the Bristol Merchant arrived into the port of Philadelphia, on 10th day 9th month 1685.[5]

“Madame Farmar” settled the land with her family in the fall of 1685, and the surroundings must have been like the Old World, all within eyesight of the neighboring “Manor of Springfield” – land located northwest of Madame Farmar that William Penn had gifted to his first wife, Gulielma Maria Springett in 1681. The entire Farmar plantation would soon become Whitemarsh Township within Montgomery County, and is so named today in the same boundary lines.

Thomas Holmes’ “A Mapp of Ye Improved Part of Pensilvania in America, Divided Into Countyes, Townships and Lotts….” (published circa 1687). Farmar’s plantation located in the center of the map, in present Whitemarsh Township.

Lime was manufactured in Whitemarsh at a very early day, and probably earlier than at any other place in the province. In a letter from Dr. Nicholas More,[6] a physician from London, Chief Justice, and President of the Free Society of Traders, dated from his residence at Green Spring, in the manor of Moreland, 13 September 1686, to William Penn, then in England, that…

“Madame Farmar has found out as good limestone on the Schuylkill as any in the world, and is building with it; she offers to sell ten thousand bushels at sixpence the bushel upon her plantation, where are several considerable hills, and near to your manor of Springfield.”[7]

Madame Farmar was not only optimistic and energetic, but an astute and proven business woman, frequently mentioned with very great respect. James Logan writing to William Penn of Madame Farmer, says “she is a woman of great business ability, and tact.”

Madame Farmar died in late 1686, leaving her estate to her surviving 14-year-old son Edward Farmar. Beginning in the early 1690s, Edward began buying land and selling parcels of the original 5000 patent in 100- to 200-acre plots. The sales served two purposes, one of which was to raise money to cover his expenses, and the other was to satisfy one of the agreement terms when the land was purchased from William Penn. Penn had stipulated that the property was to be subdivided as it was never his intention to re-create a large feudal estate in America as existed in England and Ireland.

In a letter from William Penn to James Logan, Penn references Edward’s desire to confirm ownership of 100 acres in the Manor of Springfield and to sell him an additional 100 acres for £100, a request not satisfied until 1713.

London 28th 5 m 1702
“…pray quiet ed. Farmer, J. Growden, &c: till my son comes, unless I should have more time to [be] perticuler now, w’ch is doubtfull, the winde being faire, after long westerly winds… For the land, It is asking me so much mony out of my pocket. Nor will I let it goe for 4 or 500 acres, but to reduce his other pretentions, & give security for the overplus of the value, if any. And in case it ever was a part of the Mannor of Springfield, I can part with such a quantity. But more of this per my son; only tell ed. Farmer no body else, if not he, shall have a foot of the land requests of me. vale.”[8]

With all of the land buying and selling, Edward has not sold enough property in forty-four years to satisfy William Penn’s agreement with his father Major Jasper Farmar and his brother Jasper Farmar, Jr. as evidenced by the minutes of the Assembly on 11th day 12th month 1734/5:

“That the late Prop’r was pleased to Grant to his father and Uncles who were purchasers of the Tract of 5,000 Acres of Land since called White Marsh the Priviledge of two Fairs every Year and a Market once a Week to be kept on the said Tract of Land provided that within five years they should procure twenty familys to settle and dwell there, which he confesses was not complyed with…”[9]

Edward was commissioned as one of the Justices of the Peace for Philadelphia County on 02 September 1701, and again on 04 September 1704.[10] It was an office he would hold for twenty-six consecutive years to 1727, and again continuously from 1728 until his death in 1745 for a span of over forty years.

For Edward, the office gave him the opportunity to work with his 25-year-old nephew Thomas Farmar, the son of Edward’s brother Jasper Jr. and Widow Katherine, who had made the trip to Pennsylvania at the age of ten on the Bristol Merchant. Thomas was personally appointed by William Penn as the High Sheriff of Philadelphia City and County on 20 June 1700 and was appointed again in 1701.

Part of his duties was to act as a water bailiff with the power to execute all legal process against any person, ship, or goods upon the Delaware River. Believing that the commission infringed upon his authority, Governor Robert Quary of Carolina complained on 14 November 1700 to the Lords of the Admiralty and the responsibilities were removed from Thomas.[11] As High Sheriff, Thomas was to keep the peace and enforce the law, while his uncle Edward Farmar as Justice of the Peace would have tried the cases and meted the punishment to those Thomas arrested. Among his other duties was to collect taxes, a task he did not do well for fear of making himself unpopular with the citizens who did not like the levies. After Edward Shippen,[12] Nathan Stanbury, Isaac Norris, and William Carter made a complaint to the Council on 03 February 1702, the responsibility was then relegated to William Tonge who was appointed on recommendation of the Governor and Council as “under sheriff” to collect the taxes and do it promptly.[13] Additionally, John Furnis was also employed by William Penn in 1701 to collect the £2000 tax in the town, “after Thomas Farmer had failed to discharge his Duty therein.”[14]

Thomas held the office until he resigned his commission in August 1703 with a desire to move back to England as noted in the Council minutes.

“Thomas Farmar High Sheriff of the City and County of Philadelphia acquainted ye Board that having a design to transport himself to England he must crave leave to lay down his said office, and therefore requested the Board that another might be appointed.”[15]

Another Farmar-Penn connection occurs on 22 August 1751, when 27-year-old Lady Juliana Fermor, Edward’s third cousin-twice removed, marries 49-year-old Thomas Penn, the son of William Penn, in St. George’s Church in Hanover. A section has been included in the book Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh.

[1] Penn, “William Penn’s Journal of His Second Visit to Ireland,” p.59.

[2] Penn, “William Penn’s Journal of His Second Visit to Ireland,” p.59, p.62, p.63, p.65. Penn’s use of the abbreviations “F.” or “ff.” may also reference Major Jasper, but have been omitted. References to “M. ffarmer” and other various spellings denotes Major Jasper, whereas the omission of “M.” may be to Jasper’s brother John.

[3] Farmer, “Thomas Farmer, Jamestown Adventurer:  His History, Descendants, & Ancestors,” p.15-16. Major Jasper Farmar’s grandfather, George Fermor, and Thomas Farmer’s father, John Farmer of Cookham, were second cousins as both were the great grandchildren of Thomas Richards alias Fermor. It is highly questionable if Major Jasper (born 1610) knew Thomas Farmer (born 1593) as Major Jasper was age six when Thomas departed for Virginia in 1616. It is possible that during the return trips Thomas made to England, that he did meet Major Jasper, or news of Thomas’ stories in America from other relatives may have reached Major Jasper.

[4] Bean, History of Montgomery County, p.1139.

[5] Mann, “Fort Washington Historic Environs,” p.203 states “September 10, 1685” possibly due to a mistranslation between Julian and Gregorian calendars.

[6] Bean, History of Montgomery County, p.vii of Appendix. Nicholas More, a physician from London, arrived soon after William Penn, in 1682, and had conveyed to him by patent, 7th of Sixth Month, 1684, the manor of Moreland, containing nine thousand eight hundred and fifteen acres. About 1685 he commenced thereon the erection of buildings, where he lived and died, calling the place Green Spring.

[7] Bean, History of Montgomery County, p.1139; Hobson et al., Centennial Celebration of Montgomery County, p.53; Published in Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, vol. 4, p. 445.

[8] Dunn, et al., The Papers of William Penn, Volume 4:  1701-1718, p.179 & p.181. Joseph Growden claimed 14,000 acres between Poquessing Creek and Neshaminy Creek, but William Penn had agreed to a total of 10,000 acres if Growden could find his father’s deed, and only 5000 acres if not.

[9] Cook, “Farmar of Ardevalaine,” p.97. From the minutes of 11th day 12th month 1734/5.

[10] Reference Martin’s Bench and Bar of Philadelphia for additional dates and Justices.

[11] Dunn, et al., The Papers of William Penn, Volume 4:  1701-1718, p.75.

[12] Edward Shippen (1639-1712), a wealthy Quaker merchant, Mayor, Speaker of the Assembly, Chief Justice, and president of the Provincial Council. Born in Methley, Yorkshire, England, he removed to Boston, Massachusetts, in 1668 and then to Philadelphia in 1693-1694. His “Great House,” which was on Second Street, north of Spruce, and overlooked Dock Creek and the river beyond, was occupied for a time in 1699 by William Penn and his family during his second visit (Myers, Narratives of Early Pennsylvania, West New Jersey, and Delaware, 1630-1707, p.332).

[13] Browning, “Philadelphia Business Directory of 1703,” p.734; Scharf, History of Philadelphia, 1609-1884, p.180.

[14] Roach, Colonial Philadelphians, p.50. “John Furnis,barber in 1701, had arrived in October 1683 with his father Henry Furnis, and relatives most of whom, including John , were indentured to Robert Turner for four years. Henry took up on rent in 1685 a 50 by 100 foot lot at the northwest corner of Vine and Second Street “in the Governor’s Land adjoining the city;” here he, a sadler by trade, was taxed on an estate rated at £30 in 1693. In 1701, when John Furnis applied for the headland due his relatives, amounting in all to 350 acres, he [was appointed by Penn].”

[15] Minutes of the Provincial Council, vol. 2, p.66.

Philip Farmer is currently assisting families break down their genealogical brick walls and find information on their ancestors. He is also the author and publisher of “Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh,” a 500-page, 155-year biographical history of the Farmer family’s immigration from Ireland into Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Virginia, Tennessee, and Harlan County, Kentucky.

Very well written and researched…”
Ms. L. King

UPDATE: First Hanging in Harlan County?

An update based on reader-submitted “evidence” regarding the oral history that Hezekiah Clem was the first person hanged in Harlan County in 1860.

From June 29 to July 5, a four-part blog was written about Hezekiah Clem. An analysis of the oral tradition raises doubts whether he was the first person executed by hanging in Harlan County, Kentucky.

An open request for information that supported or refuted the claim was provided on July 20 from a reader:

“Hezekiah Clem did indeed hang in Harlan, Ky. in 1860 for the murder of Ben Irvin. There are even pictures of him hanging. I have one myself…”

After an exchange of emails, the reader was kind to provide the referenced picture, sent as a 260×318 JPG:

click to enlarge

After years of examining old photographs for dating clues, locations, and other information, I immediately had my doubts. If this was an actual photo that had been digitized, either by scanning or by photograph, then it must have been cropped. This makes it difficult to determine if it was a genuine 1860 photo.

At first glance, it appeared to have a few issues.

To start, the picture does not have the tone common with photos from the 1860’s, and the brightness and contrast giving it the silhouette effect was troubling. Giving the benefit of the doubt, this could have occurred during the digitizing process.

I also noticed the hand(s) and wondered why they weren’t bound with cuffs or rope. However, when looking through other vintage photos of public hangings, there are some convicts that do not have their hands bound.

The account of the hanging states that Clem “was taken there, and a wagon driven under a tree. A rope was tied around his neck and to a branch of the tree, and the wagon was then driven out from under him…” If so, why are the feet so low to the ground? Why use so much rope?

Imagine a wagon under the tree in the photo. This person’s head would be in the leaves, with a lot of slack in the rope. With their hands untied, and the rope slack, what prevents them from hanging on the branch, preventing the noose from tightening, and using the other hand to free themselves?

Looking at the feet, there appears to be something that the person once stood on, making this look more like a suicide than an execution.

While all of the issues above are circumstantial and raises a lot of alternative questions and answers, the most glaring inaccuracies are shown in the lower left and lower right corners.

Pictured in the lower left corner is what appears to be a 55-gallon steel drum with the reinforcing chimes (“ridges”). The earliest steel drum did not appear until 1905.

https://aoghs.org/transportation/nellie-bly-oil-drum/

In the lower right corner are three stacked tires. Judging by the dimensions, these tires would not be around until 1925, at the earliest, and quite possibly much later.

http://www.earlyamericanautomobiles.com/1917.htm
click to enlarge

After doing a reverse Google image search, the earliest date this picture was posted to the internet (as of the time of this blog) was 2009. And it appears everywhere, most associated with the title of a hanging woman, and most associated with news articles about male hangings in Asia. The picture also appears as the background for several memes.

In my opinion, the photo is not of Hezekiah Clem.

Do you agree, or disagree?

Philip Farmer is currently assisting families break down their genealogical brick walls and find information on their ancestors. He is also the author and publisher of “Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh,” a 500-page, 155-year biographical history of the Farmer family immigration from Ireland into Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Virginia, Tennessee, and Harlan County, Kentucky.

Very well written and researched…”
Ms. L. King

John Farmer, Father of Stephen?

A lot of family trees exist today with John Farmer as the father of Stephen Farmer. Focusing on published works, we examine the evidence that the information contained in those trees is incorrect.

John Farmer (1789-1838), “the founder of systematic genealogy in America…”

When branching my family tree, I’ve been led down wrong paths with misdirection or misinformation, particularly when it becomes too easy to simply copy and paste another researcher’s family tree, only to dig deeper and find that the hours to build a branch were all for naught. Today’s blog hopes to point other Farmer family researchers in the correct direction when branching their family tree.

There are several publicly available family trees on several genealogical, historical society, and self-published internet sites that have John Farmer as the father of Stephen Farmer (born circa 1765). Focusing on published works, we examine the evidence that the information contained in those trees is incorrect. You are invited to conduct a search and determine that there are a large number of family trees that may need to be revised; below is just a small sample:

https://www.geni.com/people/Stephen-Farmer/6000000010898877738
http://www.mcfarlandfamilies.com/getperson.php?personID=I02406&tree=1
http://www.seventyyearsinthecoalmines.org/AncestorsPBF.htm
http://www.pcahs.com/pcaolr/database/acdpcd-p/p555.htm
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Farmer-527

Most of the information is relatively the same:  that Stephen Farmer is the son of Lt. John N. Farmer (born 17 DEC 1737, Billerica, MA) and Hannah Davis (sometimes Rebecca Bryan). Further, Stephen’s siblings are listed as Hannah (Farmer) Hopkins, Rebecca Farmer, Abigail (Farmer) French, Polly (Farmer) Rogers, John Farmer and Lucy (Farmer) Tewksbury.

With regards to published works, the earliest known book with this data is Genealogy of the Farmer Family (1966) by Mattie Shepherd, Opal Muncy, David Farmer, and W.G. Farmer:

Shepherd, Mattie, Opal Muncy, David, Farmer, and W.G. Farmer. Genealogy of the Farmer Family (1966), p.1-2.

“Edward Farmer lived near Atherstone, Warwickshire England, until he and his mother immigrated to America in 1671 settling in Billerica, Mass…

Edward Farmer died May 27, 1727 at the age of 87 years. Mary, his wife, died March 26, 1719 age 78.

Edward and Mary Farmer’s children were:

(1) Sarah Farmer married Thomas Polland Nov. 1692, died May 1725.

(2) John Farmer born Aug. 19, 1671 died Sept. 9, 1736.

(3) Edward Farmer born March 22, 1674, married a Richardson, died Dec. 17, 1752.

(4) Mary Farmer born Nov. 3, 1675 married John Dean.

(5) Barbara Farmer died 1681.

(6) Elizabeth Farmer born May 17, 1680 married William Green of Malden, Mass., May 29, 1907, died Dec. 26, 1761.

(7) Thomas Farmer, born June 8, 168l He was the great grandfather of William Farmer who graduated from Harvard College 1819.

(8) Oliver Farmer, born Feb. 2, 1686, his wife’s name was Abigail. She was a granddaughter of the honorable William Johnson. Oliver died Feb. 23, 1761.

Children of Oliver Farmer were:

(1) Oliver Farmer born July 31, 1728, died at Billerica Feb. 24, 1814, leaving sons Oliver, Job, and Jeremiah.

(2) Edward Farmer born March 24, 1734, a magistrate and representative of Billerica for 14 years, died Aug. 4, 1804 age 70. His sons were Jona and Jesse.

(3) John Farmer born Dec. 17, 1737 died at Billerica on Jan. 9, 1806 leaving one son, John Farmer, who was a colonel and a representative of a town in New Hampshire.

Note: The above was taken from the Historical and Biographical Sketch of The Farmer Family compiled by The American Research Bureau of Washington, D. C. and The Genealogical Registers of the First Settlers of New England by John Farmer corresponding secretary of the New Hampshire Historical Society published by Carter Andrews & Co., Lancaster, Mass 1829.

The following were given to me by my people who lived during my lifetime (Mattie Shepherd) according to information given me, I believe that this John Farmer is the father of the Stephen Farmer who married Nancy Russell and lived in Harlan County as late as 1812…”

There are numerous other books that can definitively prove that Stephen Farmer’s ancestors are NOT from Billerica, Massachusetts. The following is a guide to find the information within the source documents.

The first source is A Genealogical Memoir of the Family By The Name Of Farmer, Who Settled At Billerica, first published in 1828 by a direct descendant to the Farmer’s in Billerica, John Farmer (1789-1838), famed author, historian, and “founder of systematic genealogy in America.” It provides a lot of information regarding the sons, fathers, wives, and children of almost every Farmer in Billerica. It has been published in the source below:

Waters, Henry F. The New England Historical and Genealogical Register (1847), p.25, 27, 29, & 30.

“Edward, (ca1640 – 27MAY1727, Billerica, MA) m. Mary ___ (ca1641 – 26MAR1716)

Oliver (02FEB1686-23FEB1761) m. Abigail Johnson (13JUN1697-25FEB1773). Widow Abigail m.2nd Capt. James Lane of Bedford, Ms.

Lieut. John (07DEC1737-09JAN1806 Billerica) m.1st 05JUN1764 Hannah Davis (07SEP1711-12FEB1787) m.2nd widow Sarah (Russell) Adams (18JAN1751-?)

With his wife Hannah,

Hannah (26SSEP1764-?)

Rebecca (02DEC1766-29MAY1788)

Abigail (22DEC1768-?)

Polly (14JAN1775-?

John (04DEC1776-01SEP1778)

Lucy (04OCT1780-?)

John (11DEC1791-?) m. Susan Gerrish. Lt. Col. of the 21st regiment of NH militia…”

As shown above, there are no Stephen’s born to John and Hannah Davis, and any of other John’s born into the other related families were either in 1776 (and died under the age of two years old), or born in 1791. Mathematically, those John’s cannot be the father of Stephen. Therefore, the other trees having Stephen’s siblings as Hannah Farmer Hopkins, Rebecca Farmer, Abigail Farmer French, Polly Farmer Rogers, John Farmer, and Lucy Farmer Tewksbury is incorrect; they are the names of the children of John and Hannah Davis as shown in the source above.

The next source is the Billerica Vital Records that not only verify the Farmer Genealogical Memoir, but also shows the marriage between “John Farmer and Sarah Adams of Dracut marrying on 18 March 1789, in Dracut.” It was also used to answer a few hypothetical questions:

Foster, F. Apthorp. Vital Records of Billerica, Massachusetts to the Year 1850 (1908), p. 72-75 (births), 252-253 (marriages), & 358-359 (deaths).

Hypothesis #1:  John has a son named Stephen or William that isn’t mentioned in the first record?
Answer:  There is no record of a Stephen (or William) born to a John in Billerica around 1765.

(Note:  Walker-Burton, Jackie T. Turner’s Creek, Ky., ‘A Place In Our Hearts’ (1997), p.204-205, mentions “The family and oral traditions say that Stephen Farmer was son of John Farmer, Sr…” and “Very old family members believed his name was Wm. Stephen Farmer…”)

Hypothesis #2:  Stephen was the son of Sarah Russell Adams and later changed his name to Farmer?
Answer:  There is no record of a Stephen, William, or any male born around 1765 with the last name of Adams nor Russell.

Hypothesis #3:  Hannah Davis had a son prior to her marriage to John who changes his name?
Answer:  There is a William Daves, son of Joshua and Hannah, born 28 March 1761 in Billerica. There is no death or marriage record for Joshua Daves (or Davis, or Davise) that matches our search. There is a Joshua and Hannah, but their ages do not coincide and there is a birth record for their daughter Hannah Davis, born 07 September 1641. Does William Daves, son of our Hannah Davis, change his name to Farmer, and move away? There is no marriage or death record in Billerica for a William Daves, which may support this.

The next source then refuted Hypothesis #3 above, not contained in the first two documents:

Razen, Rev. Henry A. History of Billerica, Massachusetts with A Genealogical Register (1883), p.40.

“6. William [DAVIS], son of Joshua, 2, b. 1761, March 28: m. Rebecca ___ Ch. William. B. 1790, Sept. 9. Lydia Merriam, b. 1793, April 23…”

The next source is the 1790 Census in Billerica for a “John Farmer”:

Quantity 1 for “free white male of 16 years old and upwards.”
This would be head of household John.

Quantity 2 for “free white males under 16 years.”
Unknown. As John was born in 1791, this rules him out. Possibly one of Sarah’s sons from her prior marriage.

Quantity 3 for “free white females.”
Presumably his wife Sarah, Polly, and Lucy as Hannah died three years earlier in 1787, and Rebecca two years earlier in 1788.

Another hypothesis is that John mentions Stephen in his will? John died intestate and only letters of administration were sent to his wife Sarah.

In addition to the reputable published evidence, DNA testing refutes any connection to the Farmer’s from Billerica. In an email with Chuck Farmer on 02 March 2018,

“The Billerica link is definitively OUT. My grandfather was involved in writing “The Genealogy of the Farmer Family” that posed that possibility. I have disproved it with DNA. My 12 marker test showed major differences between our branch and the Billerica folks…”

There was one item of interest that may warrant some further investigation. John Farmer’s wife was born Sarah Russell. Stephen Farmer’s wife was Nancy Russell. More research may be needed to determine if family lore of Stephen’s relation to John has been confused with Nancy Russell’s distant relation to Sarah Russell. This may be further supported by the David Russell who serves for the Continental Line in New Hampshire during the Revolutionary War under Lieutenant John Farmer.

So who is Stephen Farmer’s father? The answer is William Farmer, the son of Samuel Farmer and the grandson of Edward Farmar of Whitemarsh Township, Pennsylvania.

Philip Farmer is currently assisting families break down their genealogical brick walls and find information on their ancestors. He is also the author and publisher of “Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh,” a 500-page, 155-year biographical history of the Farmer family immigration from Ireland into Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Virginia, Tennessee, and Harlan County, Kentucky. The continuation of Stephen Farmer’s story from 1800 into the mid-1900’s is currently in work.

The Five Baker Children: Part Four

For almost six decades, the descendants of Rosebell Baker were searching for the fathers of her children, with limited success. In Part One, we analyzed vital records and newspaper articles to determine that Samuel Chase Early was the father of Lucinda Baker. In Part Two, we determined the father of Rosebell’s other child, Meldia Baker, was Oliver Broughton. We speculated in Part Three that the identity of Axie Baker’s father is John Sidney Ingram.

When trying to identify the fathers of Cora and McKinley Baker, we are unable to find any records that can correlate them with a surname other than Baker.

While Rosebell’s son appears as “McKinley,” we speculate that his name may have been William McKinley Baker, so named after the former president of the United States. And while a “William” appears in the Kentucky school censuses, his age does not coincide with a son supposedly born in 1903 and further supported by the ages given in the federal censuses.

1900 School Census of White Children, Flat Lick – New Flat Lick – District #44

PARENT:  BAKER JAMES M [Recall James M[adison] Baker is Rosebell’s father]

CHILD (AGE)

CALHINE BAKER (17)
GROVER C. (16)
WM. (11)
LUCY (9)

Source:  http://www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~kyknox/Census/School-Census/1900-school-census-36-65.html?cj=1&netid=cj&o_xid=0001231185&o_lid=0001231185&o_sch=Affiliate+External

1904 School Census of White Children, White District No. 40, Page 159

PARENT:  ROSE BAKER

CHILD (AGE)

LUCY BAKER (12)
WILLIAM BAKER (15)
EFFIE BAKER (9)
AXIE BAKER (7)

Source:  http://www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~kyknox/Census/School-Census/1904-District-41-60.html?cj=1&netid=cj&o_xid=0001231185&o_lid=0001231185&o_sch=Affiliate+External

The theory is that the other Baker children listed in the school censuses, Calhine, Grover, Effie, and William, are cousins to Lucinda, Axie, and Meldia. With two William Bakers in the Barbourville area, Rosebell’s son was probably referred as McKinley?

Regarding McKinley, there is a 1930 federal census showing a “McKinley Baker” as an inmate in Ohio. However, when analyzing several newspaper articles from Portsmouth, Ohio, we can conclude with a high degree of certainty that the inmate is the son of James Baker residing at 1225 Linden Avenue, and former husband of Lulu Baker. Several articles have McKinley arrested on charges of domestic abuse, drunk driving, and public intoxication.

Two other records were examined to determine if any other surname may be attributed to Cora and McKinley:

Rosebell Baker’s death certificate. When examining Rosebell’s death certificate in 1955, the informant is given as “Irvin Delong.” We know that the informant is Rosebell’s son-in law, Meldia Baker’s husband, Ervin Arthur Delong (1910-1962).

click to enlarge

Lucinda Baker’s marriage license. When examining Lucinda Baker’s marriage bond, we see her maiden name listed as “Begley” and corrected to Baker. We also see she lied about her age; having been born in 1891, Lucinda would have been about eighteen years old.

click to enlarge

We’re assuming John Linville provided the information to the court clerk for the marriage bond, and that Lucinda later corrected the information when it became a marriage license.

The license is dated in 1909, six years after McKinley was born in 1903, and four years before Rosebell and Oliver Broughton gave birth to Meldia. Cora was born in 1899. The working theory based on dates is that “Begley” may have been who Rosebell was with when Lucinda was married and may have been the surname of McKinley’s father.

It’s also possible that “Begley” is Cora’s father, as John may have known that Mr. Begley had a daughter, and thought it was Lucinda, although we have a high degree of certainty that Lucinda’s father was Sam Early. Plus, as John and Sam Early (later his widowed wife Elon) were both store owners, and surely would have known each other as competitors, this doesn’t seem very plausible that John would think Lucinda’s father was Begley.

In trying to determine McKinley’s father, we come across a William Matt Begley, the son of Thomas Begley and Ama Anne “Amy” Hoskins born on 16 May 1850. William was married to Margaret Mays on 08 January 1874. They had ten children. There isn’t enough evidence that proves William is McKinley’s father, but the parallels are very similar:

  • Lucinda was probably named after Rosebell’s aunt. Axie was probably named after her father’s sister. McKinley may have been named after a William.
  • Lucinda’s father Samuel Chase Early held a public office (sheriff). William Begley was a district magistrate.
  • Lucinda’s father Samuel Chase Early was murdered on 08 August 1909. Meldia’s father Oliver Broughton was murdered on 06 September 1918. William Begley was murdered on 26 December 1903.
click to enlarge

The only photo available of McKinley at this time was provided by a family member. If the photo looks familiar in another non-Baker family tree, please contact us.

click to enlarge

This series started with our side of the family wanting to know about Lucinda’s background. For almost six decades, those who knew the information would emphatically state “you do NOT want to know that…” Whatever the secret was, they all took it with them when they passed away. Could it be the shame of being an illegitimate child? This doesn’t seem believable as social morals and norms changed over the years. Perhaps it was the murder of Lucinda’s father… something most families keep hidden. But how is it that four other families didn’t know their fathers either, including those whose fathers were not murdered?

We may never know.

Philip Farmer is currently assisting three families break down their genealogical brick walls and find information on their ancestors. He is also the author and publisher of “Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh,” a 500-page, 155-year biographical history of the Farmer’s immigration from Ireland into Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Virginia, Tennessee, and Harlan County, Kentucky. The continuation of Stephen Farmer’s story from 1800 into the mid-1900’s is currently in work.

The Five Baker Children: Part 3

For almost six decades, the descendants of Rosebell Baker were searching for the fathers of her children, with limited success. In Part One, we analyzed vital records and newspaper articles to determine that Samuel Chase Early was the father of Lucinda Baker . In Part Two, we determined the father of Rosebell’s other child, Meldia Baker, was Oliver Broughton. We continue the story with the identity of Axie Baker’s father.

By poring over the available records and networking with other family members, we know Rosebell’s children to be Lucinda, Axie, Cora, McKinley, and Meldia… all from different fathers. When we concluded Part Two, we mentioned how associates, such as family or friends, may provide clues in identifying the fathers of Rosebell’s other children. Associates were most helpful in postulating the father of Axie Baker.

In an email dated 07 March 2018 from Ms. Freeda Gay (Jones) Pease, granddaughter of Axie Baker thru her son Paul:

“I am the granddaughter of Axie Jane Baker; my father was Paul F[erman] Jones. I am resuming the ancestry search that my aunt, [Bessie] Jean [(Jones)] Taylor began years ago! Before Jean Taylor died, she mentioned to me that she thought she had discovered the names of Cora’s and Axie’s fathers. When I inherited her research notebooks, that info was not included.

Axie Baker Jones, my grandmother, was married to Mack Jones and had 10 children… After my grandmother died in 1990, my aunt Jean Taylor told me that Grannie Jones (Axie) and her siblings all had different fathers, and they all had the last name Baker.

Axie Baker

b.7 Feb 1895 d. 8 May 1990

m.5 Jan 1916 Mack Jones b. 14 Apr 1894 d. 10 Jan 1947

Both are buried in the Corinth Cemetery, Corbin, KY.

Mack Jones worked for L&N railroad, Corbin, KY. He died young when my dad, Paul F. Jones, was a senior in high school. Dad had to drop out of school to work full time. He and his sister (Jean Taylor) worked to support the family and helped raise their younger siblings.”

In an email dated 11 October 2017, Ms. Suzanne Dungan, the great granddaughter of Rosebell Baker thru Axie’s sister Meldia provides additional information as follows:

“I corresponded with Jean Taylor who was the daughter of Axie Baker and Mack Jones. She passed in 2011 and had done some genealogy on her family… I cannot find my documentation of my email from Jean Taylor which was a number of years ago…”

What we also know is that there is a Rose Belle Baker marrying a William Spivy in 1887 in Lee County; further research shows that this Rose is not Axie’s mother. There is no 1900 Federal Census record with any combination or name variation of Rosebell and/or Axie. Nor could we find Axie in the Kentucky School Censuses.

A 1910 Federal Census has a Vina Baker (widowed), and a Rose, Axie, Cora, and McKinley living next door in West Flat Lick Precinct No. 6:

click to enlarge

Note Ike Patterson b.1855 and Lizzie Patterson b.1855 living next door to Rosebell. The Patterson’s and Ingram’s have a family connection that is important to support the theory on Axie’s father.

In searching available, online newspaper archives, only one article appears for every possible Axie +Baker +Jones +Ingram combination.

click to enlarge

Elon Keele (1873-1931) was the wife of Samuel Chase Early (1867-1909). Five years prior to his marriage to Elon in 1897, Samuel and Rosebell have a daughter Lucinda Baker (1892-1963), who is Axie’s half-sister. Ten months after Samuel’s murder on 08 August 1909, 37-year old Elon and her only child, 18-month-old son Samuel Coone Early (1908-1988), travel to see Elon’s widowed 74-year old father Jesse. She is accompanied by 15-year old Axie Baker.

The theory is that Axie was a nanny or volunteered to help as a plausible explanation for her joining the trip with further information from Ms. Pease:

“My grandmother [Axie] and Cora evidently had a hard life. Rose did laundry for people and the kids helped. I was told that they worked at a young age. Someone mentioned that “Grannie [Axie] was farmed out” when she was young to other families to take care of their kids!”

Elon took over Samuel’s store in Barboursville after his death and expanded it. Lucinda’s husband, John Linville, also ran (and lived above) a store in Barboursville, and as a competitor, Elon may have known Lucinda, may have known Lucinda was her widowed husband’s daughter, and perhaps knew Axie and Lucinda were sisters. As noted in the 1910 federal census, Elon was living four houses down from Rosebell’s first cousin, Christopher “Kit” Baker, and may have known Axie during her visits with relatives.

Having married Mack Jones in 1916, Axie does not appear with Rose, McKinley, and “Alvina” (misspelling of Meldia) in the 1920 Federal Census:

click to enlarge

So how do we prove the identity of Axie’s father?

There is a record for Axie Baker as “Axie Ingram.” The Kentucky Birth Index for Axie and Mack’s son, William Dallas Jones (1918-2005), has mother listed  as “Alie Ingram.”[1]

Name:  William D Jones
Date of Birth:  23 Nov 1918
Birth Place:  Whitley, Kentucky, USA
Mother’s name:  Alie Ingram
Volume Number:  111
Certificate Number:  55349
Volume Year:  1918

When searching for “Axie”, several variations based on transcription errors do occur, such as Alie, Anie, etc. The last name Ingram implies…

  • Ingram is Axie’s last name regardless of father. Considering Axie’s name has been consistent as “Axie Baker” and this is the only instance of the use of Ingram, we can rule this out.

OR

  • Ingram is the name of Axie’s husband. Considering that William is her second out of nine children, and that the birth index of her children before and after William have “Axie Baker” as mother, we can rule this out.

OR

  • Ingram is the name of Axie’s father.

Axie is also listed as “Axie Ingram” in The Jones Family Tree on Ancestry.com, managed by MikeRuthAnnEvenson as of 08MAR2018, with Rose Bell Baker as the mother, but no documentation that points to the father.

Also, other family trees have data for Axie Baker with father as Mat Baker and mother as Rose (Baker) Holmes (reference Jones Family Tree managed by dejoneswa). Many records do show that Mat Baker was married to Sarah Gray, but with no child named Axie, nor is there any known relationship between Mat Baker and Rosebell Baker.

There is only one Ingram in Flat Lick. In prior research when tracing the unknown fathers of Rose’s daughters Lucinda and Meldia, we find that their respective fathers were residing in Flat Lick in 1900 and were lifelong residents:

  • Samuel Chase Early (1869-1909), father of Lucinda Baker (see Part One). Farmer, merchant, sheriff. Marries Elon Keel in 1897. Murdered on 08 August 1909.
  • Oliver Broughton (1890-1918), father of Meldia Baker (see Part Two). Soldier stationed at Camp Zachary Taylor. Murdered on 06 September 1918.

When browsing the 1900 Federal Census, the most recent and available census close to Axie’s birth, these are the only Ingram’s residing in Flat Lick, Knox County, Kentucky:

  • Sidney INGRAM, b.JUN 1869, a.31, single, occupation “farmer”
  • Ollie INGRAM, sister to Sidney, b.SEP 1875, a.24, single
  • Frank INGRAM, brother to Sidney, b.SEP 1878, a.21, occupation “farm laborer”
  • Claude INGRAM, nephew to Sidney, b.JUN 1893, a.6
click to enlarge

Going back thru the census, we find Sidney, Ollie, and [Benjamin] Frank[lin]’s parents James and Margaret INGRAM, and conclude that the family members have been residents of Flat Lick for many years.

Realizing that Frank could be the father (he would have been aged fifteen in 1894, nine months before Axie was born in February 1895), we continue in a chronological order focusing on Sidney Ingram, who is Rosebell’s age.

When determining family members, the following resource is very helpful:

Rev. Ebenezer Ingram settled at what is now known as Ingram, Kentucky, post office. This office was named after him. He served as Chaplain in the Civil War in the 49th Kentucky, Voluntary Infantry, composed of ten companies. He had the following family:
(1) Thomas J. Ingram, who had a large family of children, one of whom, Judge Eb Ingram, who was County Judge of Bell County, and was one of the leading political figures of the county for a generation;
(2) Polly Ingram (the oldest of the family);
(3) Rev. James Queener Ingram, who lived and died near Williamsburg, Kentucky;
(4) William F. Ingram; 1852-1885;
(5) Elsie Ingram,

(6) Hannah Ingram;
(7) Amanda Ingram,
(8) Sallie Ingram,
(9) Peggy Ingram,
(10) Emily Ingram.

James W. Ingram, father of Sidney Ingram, who now lives in Harlan, Kentucky, was a son of William F. Ingram. James W. Ingram was born and reared in the Ingram Settlement, but went to Flat Lick in Knox County where he died, and was buried in the McRoberts Graveyard in Bell County near the mouth of Greasy Creek, on the old Frank Creech farm. James W. Ingram had the following children:

  1. First wife: Betty Tinsley: [Elizabeth]

(1) Bill,
(2) Mary Partin,
(3) Josephine Gibson,
(4) Hannah Gibson,
(5) America Garrett,
(6) Jim Ingram,
(7) Damia,
(8) John,
(9) Elbert,
(10) Betty Gardner,
(11) Sudie Warren,
(12) Margaret Hendrickson.

II Second wife: Margaret Tinsley:

(13) Elizabeth,
(14) Mellie,
(15) Sidney,
(16) Cordia, [Gorden?]
(17) Ellen, [Susan?]
(18) Ollie,
(19) Frank, [Benjamin Franklin]
(20) Edna,
(21) Axie.[2]

Axie Baker may have been named after Sidney’s sister. That Sidney had a sister by the name of Axie may imply a family name was provided by Sidney when Rosebell gave birth; however, given the popularity of Axie at the turn of the century, this theory is questionable and Rosebell may have simply picked a popular name. Note however that the name Axie is passed throughout both the Ingram and Baker generations, starting with Sidney’s sister. Axie’s sister Lucinda names one of her daughters Axie Belle..

No birth dates are provided for Sidney’s sister to determine if the theory is correct, although her exclusion from the 1880 census implies she was born after 1880. She is NOT the Axie Ingram (19NOV1887 – 30MAR1913, a.25) per Find A Grave Memorial #14277157; that person is Axie (Dean) Ingram (19NOV1871-30MAR1913), wife of Sidney’s brother Elbert P. Ingram.

It’s probably a safe assumption that “Axie B. Ingram”, b.MAY 1896, listed as a daughter to John and America Ingram in the 1900 Federal Census, Kentucky, Whitley, Woodbine, District 0138, Sheet 22, really is John and America’s daughter.

The Social Security Application and Claims Index confirms Sidney’s birth date and parents as:

Name:  Sidney Ingram
Gender:  Male

Race:  White
Birth Date:  2 Jan 1869
Birth Place:  Bell, Kentucky
Father:  James W Ingram
Mother:  Margaret Tinsley
SSN: 400242849
Notes:  Aug 1940: Name listed as SIDNEY INGRAM

The note above is important, implying that Sidney was known by a “different” name. More on his full name is provided below.

Looking at the 1870 federal census, we find the following:

click to enlarge

Where is Sidney if he was born in 1869 and not included in the 1870 census above? When trying to find Sidney, we find three possibilities, with the most plausible explanation below, and more information in the footnote.[3] Note that the 1870 census does not specify relationships.

click to enlarge

As difficult as the sheet is to read, whoever indexed the census has John Sidney aged 3, but it could very well be a strong 1, or a weak 6.

click to enlarge

It is my opinion that in 1870,

  • William L. Tinsley and wife Margaret are residing in his parents’ home.
  • John Sidney Tinsley, son of William and Margaret Tinsley, is residing with his paternal grandparents.
  • It’s after Margaret’s marriage in April 1873 when John Sidney lives with James W. Ingram.
  • Fuson’s account of the Ingram family tree may be in error.
click to enlarge

The 1870 federal census is the only mention of his name being “John Sidney” and is included for future reference and searching criteria; however, as the majority of documents refer to him as Sidney, we’ll maintain the latter.

click to enlarge

In 1896, it is highly likely that our Sidney Ingram was involved with a stabbing altercation with Charles Herndon. Two newspaper articles are included below, although there are numerous other articles on Herndon, one of which describes Ingram of Flat Lick, and again, the 1900 census shows only one Sidney Ingram in Flat Lick.

click to enlarge

In the spring of 1896, 35-year-old Charles Herndon of Flat Lick married 21-year-old Elizabeth Taylor. A few days after their marriage, they separate on account of his alleged brutal treatment of her. Herndon said that Elizabeth had been guilty of liaisons with two men:  Herndon stabs 27-year-old “Sydney Ingram” in a quarrel, whom he accused of “being on too intimate terms” with his wife, and he accuses Elizabeth of deserting him for Galloway Carnes. Herndon serves nine months in the Kentucky penitentiary in Frankfort for stabbing Ingram. During his incarceration, Elizabeth went to live with her mother, Mrs. Martha Taylor. Herndon is released from prison sometime in December 1896,  where he travels from Flat Lick, Knox County to Jellico Creek, Whitley County, and shoots his wife in the head on December 23. Elizabeth’s 10-year-old brother witnessed the murder. A fugitive for twelve years, Herndon is arrested on 30 January 1909 while hiding in Byers, Colorado with a nephew.

Note that the stabbing occurred about one year after Axie was born. It is unknown if Sidney and Elizabeth really were intimate, or if a jealous Herndon simply perceived there were shenanigans.

Issac/Ike and Elizabeth/Lizzie Patterson lived next door to both Sidney Ingram and Rosebell Baker. More research may be needed to find the correlation between the Ingram’s and Patterson’s:

  • In 1860, H.Patterson and Martha Patterson are living with Ebenezer Ingram, a relative of Sidney. The census is ambiguous with regards to race… the “color” column for Ebenezer, Rachel, Jonathan, and Williams is blank, yet there is a “1” for Mary Jane and James (presumably both Ingram), and for the Patterson’s?
click to enlarge
  • In 1900, Isaac Patterson b.JAN1854 (a.45) and Elizabeth Patterson b.JUL1853 (a.47), a black family, are living next door to Sidney Ingram.
  • In 1910, Ike Patterson a.55 (b. abt. 1855) and Lizzie Patterson a.55 (b. abt. 1855), a black family, are living next door to Rosebell Baker.
click to enlarge

Additional information for Sidney and his family is as follows:

click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge

Sidney dies on 24 January 1941 in Harlan, Kentucky at the age of seventy-two and is buried at Resthaven Cemetery:

click to enlarge

With this information, the family tree looks like this:

click to enlarge

The information above is circumstantial, and we’re asking for any family members, particularly anyone on the Ingram side who may have additional information to share, to please contact us.

To be continued in Part Four

[1] Kentucky Department for Libraries and Archives. Kentucky Birth, Marriage, and Death Databases: Births 1911-1999. Frankfort, Kentucky: Kentucky Department for Libraries and Archives.

[2] Fuson, Henry Harvey. History of Bell County Kentucky, Volume 1 (30 August 1939). Structure edited for clarity and emphasis added. Note that “James W. Ingram, father of Sidney Ingram, who now lives in Harlan, Kentucky, was buried in the McRoberts Graveyard in Bell County near the mouth of Greasy Creek…” which is an area that Oliver Broughton, the father of Meldia, would visit his relatives.

[3] Where is Sidney in the 1870 federal census if he was born in 1869? Absent from his family’s household, we find two other possibilities:

click to enlarge
click to enlarge

Philip Farmer is currently assisting three families break down their genealogical brick walls and find information on their ancestors. He is also the author and publisher of “Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh,” a 500-page, 155-year biographical history of the Farmer’s immigration from Ireland into Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Virginia, Tennessee, and Harlan County, Kentucky. The continuation of Stephen Farmer’s story from 1800 into the mid-1900’s is currently in work.

The Five Baker Children: Part 2

For almost six decades, the descendants of Rosebell Baker were searching for the fathers of her children, with limited success. In Part One, we analyzed vital records and newspaper articles to determine that the father of Lucinda Baker was Samuel Chase Early. We continue the story to determine the father of Rosebell’s other child, Meldia Baker.

Soon after posting the information about Lucinda Baker, and about her parents Rosebell Baker and Samuel Chase Early, I was contacted by Ms. Suzanne Dungan on 11 October 2017 with the following information:

“The Rose Baker with Axie, Cora and McKinley is Lucinda’s mother, and my grandmother’s mom. The line is as follows:
William Baker and Elizabeth Walker

James Madison Baker and Melvina Smith (from Lee Co. Virginia, daughter of William Smith and Elizabeth Edwards)

Rosabel Baker of Flat Lick, Ky.

Children:

Lucinda Baker (md. John B. Linville)

Axie Baker md. Mack Jones (lived in Whitley Co. Ky.)

Cora Baker

McKinley Baker  there are at least 2 in Knox Co. and their birthdays are close which is really confusing!)

Meldia Baker (my grandmother)

My mom lived with “Granny Rose” for approximately 6-8 years as her mother, Meldia, worked in Corbin, KY and visited on weekends. Mom stated that Granny Rose “ruled the roost” and was very strict and god-fearing. She didn’t like census takers and government, etc. and stated that if a man married you in the church that you didn’t need to go to the county seat and buy a piece of paper to make it a marriage. She also told Mom that if a fellow proposed…you had to wait till the traveling preacher came around….and sometimes the man was gone by then. Now Mom and I don’t know if she was speaking from experience or not, but it kind of sounded like it!”

Ms. Dungan also related how her grandmother’s name was always misspelled, which explains most of the census records. She goes on to state:

“I know my grandmother’s father was Oliver Broughton who was tragically killed when my grandmother was a young child.”

Using this information, we’re able to find the following newspaper articles and records:

click to enlarge

The Mountain Advocate (12 March 1915):

“Dewitt News

Blue Eyes

Wm Brewer and Oliver Broughton are visiting relatives in Ogle.

Ed Hubbard and Oliver Broughton were on Fighting Creek last Sunday.”

The Mountain Advocate (02 April 1915):

“Dewitt News

Blue Eyes

Oliver Broughton is visiting homefolks on Greasy Creek this week.”

The Mountain Advocate (24 August 1917):

“List of persons called into the service of the United States not exempted or discharged.

To District Board for Eastern District of Kentucky.

Local board for Knox county, State of Ky., hereby certified to district board for eastern district of Kentucky, the following list of the names and addresses of persons who have been duly and legally called for the military service of the United States, and who have not been exempted or discharged:

[many names to include]

Oliver Broughton, Flat Lick.”

Oliver’s draft card of 05 June [1917] shows that he was born 25 August 1893 in Dewitt and residing in Flat Lick. When compared to the notice in The Mountain Advocate, the draft card indicates age 24 in June, yet he would have been 24 when called into service in August. The draft card also shows he was married, presumably to Rosebell, but it is possible he may have been married to another person. Noting his age, Oliver was twenty-four years younger than Rosebell, who was born in 1869.

click to enlarge

Almost a year later, and within two weeks after his 25th birthday, Oliver was murdered as reported in The Courier Journal (07 September 1918):

“Kentucky Soldier Is Killed By Negro

Oliver Broughton, On Furlough From Camp Zachary Taylor, Is Slain

Bourbourville, KY., Sept. 6 – Corp. Oliver Broughton, home from Camp Zachary Taylor on a furlough, was shot and killed at the Knox County fairgrounds late to-day by Will Castle, a negro. Castle was shot and fatally wounded by Officer Sam Lewis as he tried to escape.

Witnesses say that Broughton accidentally stepped on the negro’s foot at a side show and Castle drew a gun and commenced shooting. Broughton, who was unarmed, was shot through the breast as he was backing away.

As his victim fell Castle wheeled to escape, but was brought down by a shot from the gun of Lewis, who was in an automobile a short distance away and who witnessed the shooting. Castle was shot through the breast and will likely not recover. Feeling is high to-night and further trouble may result.”

Three days later in the Mt. Sterling Advocate (10 September 1918):

“Guarded from Mob

A heavy guard was placed around the Knox county jail to prevent the threatened lynching of William Castle, a negro, who is charged with having shot and killed Oliver Broughton, a soldier stationed at Camp Taylor and home on a five days’ leave. Broughton, it is said, stepped on Castle’s foot and the latter, it is charged, pulled a revolver and shot Broughton through the chest. Castle in trying to escape from the police was shot through the arm.”

His death certificate also notes “homicide at the hands of Bill Castle with pistol” and also indicates he was still married, although his birth date is noted as “don’t know 1891.”

click to enlarge

Oliver and Rosebell’s daughter, Meldia, was about four years old. A year later, Oliver was exonerated from paying his taxes, and it is interesting to note that rather than stating “dead” like the other names, they annotate the reason as “killed at Fair Grounds.”

click to enlarge

The Mountain Advocate (28 November 1919):

Knox Fiscal Court, July Term, July 1, 1919

It is ordered by the Knox Fiscal Court, that R. P. Mann, Sheriff, be and he is hereby exonerated of the following list, amounting to $792.00:

District No. 1, Exonerated List.

[many names to include]

Broughton, Oliver, killed at Fair Grounds, 1.50

Of special interest is the French Memorial Service in which Oliver was honored. He may have served overseas in World War I, although more research is required to support it. It may also be that he was honored along with the many other soldiers who died, regardless of type of service.

The Mountain Advocate (27 February 1920):

French Memorial Service

The French Memorial Service which was held at Union College Chapel Sunday afternoon was a great success and Deaton-Smith Post 69 of the American Legion has once more demonstrated its ability to do the right thing in the right way. The big chapel was filled to its utmost capacity by relatives of the boys, soldiers and sailors, students and citizens.

Following the Marseillaise by Union’s fine orchestra, Dr. Leslie Logan, the Post Commander, spoke on the objects of the American Legion.

Miss Ethel Miller gave a reading, “Viva La France.” “Christ in Flanders” and “My Son,” by Carrie Jacobs Bond, were beautifully rendered by Mrs. Charles F. Rathfon.

A fine address on “One Hundred Per Cent Amercanism” was delivered by Hon. Sawyer A. Smith.

Miss Drucilla Tye ably rendered “The Americans Have Come.”

The reading of the Honor Roll was given to Mr. Bart S. Reid who also presented the certificates to the representatives of the soldier boys who had died. Representatives who were not present will receive their certificates.

The Star Spangled Banner was sung by the audience, led by the orchestra which did good work thru out.

The religious side of the ceremony was in charge of Rev. R. L. Creal and Rev. T. J. Belcher.

The four “salts” as ushers, representing the Navy in which they had served were Josh Faulkner, Ham Golden, Herbert miller and Henry Hubbard. Soldier ushers where Charlie Hendrickson, Ben Shorter, Jas. Burgess and Godfrey Parrott.

Honor roll names are: –

[many names to include]

Oliver Broughton

I often wonder if Oliver’s certificate still exists.

Of Rosebell’s children, only the descendants of Meldia seemed to know the identify of her father. With her family sharing the information, we can now trace back Oliver’s associates to see if there is a connection to the other fathers. These “association” clues became very helpful in identifying the possible father of another daughter.

To be continued in Part Three

Philip Farmer is currently assisting three families break down their genealogical brick walls and find information on their ancestors. He is also the author and publisher of “Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh,” a 500-page, 155-year biographical history of the Farmer’s immigration from Ireland into Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Virginia, Tennessee, and Harlan County, Kentucky. The continuation of Stephen Farmer’s story from 1800 into the mid-1900’s is currently in work.

The Five Baker Children: Part 1

I wish I had started genealogy research much earlier when my grandmother was still alive. With information more readily available, and armed with data from vital records, newspapers, and other records, I have so much more to ask her.

Children of Lucinda (Baker) Linville, ca. 1927, l-r: Ted, Minnie, Pearl, and Audrey.

Growing up in Battle Creek, Michigan, we would visit my grandpa and grandma, Harry and Minnie Saxman. They had a large dining table that occupied the entire kitchen of which a constant stream of family, friends, and neighbors would encircle while seven coffee makers churned out Maxwell House slower than we could drink it. Minnie had been a waitress all of her life and she always making sure her guests’ cups were full while dishing up a slice of home-baked pie, a piece of banana bread, or a ham sandwich.

Minnie always had a story to tell.

Minnie’s parents were “Poppy” and “Mama Lucy.” Poppy owned and ran a store in Barboursville while Mama Lucy ruled the roost in the apartment above it. We always heard how Poppy was sheriff of Knox County. And we always heard how she married a “no good man” and had a daughter, “Aunt Pat,” who had lived with Poppy and Mama Lucy. From time to time, Aunt Pat would come in from Virginia to visit. It wasn’t until I was older that I understood she was my father’s sister.

Minnie related how Harlan County was a “mean, violent place” and that she was a waitress in Harlan when they shot a man on the courthouse step. She later remarried to Jules Farmer, who was from Harlan County. Jules worked as a miner, but sometime in the 1940’s, his entire family moved from Harlan County to Battle Creek. Unable to find a job, Jules and Minnie moved back to Kentucky where Jules resumed coal mining. Their first son, Jules Farmer, was born in Chevrolet. Coal mining was dangerous work and Minnie did not approve. She encouraged Jules to return to Michigan where he found a job working for the Battle Creek City Sewer Department. For awhile, they lived in the former barracks of Fort Custer until they bought a new house on Ellis Road. It was this same house where we would visit, and where several of Jules’ family had also resided, to include Jules’ mother, who Minnie described as a “mean, old woman.” Jules and Minnie had three more sons:  Terry, David, and Gary.

When Jules died, Minnie remarried again to Harry. Minnie’s siblings would occasionally visit from Ohio, and while I met them, I was young and didn’t really understand who they really were.

Harry died in 1999 and Minnie died in 2004. Fourteen years later, I wish I had started genealogy research much earlier when she was still alive. With information more readily available, and armed with data from vital records, newspapers, and other records, I have so much more to ask her.

Minnie May Linville was born 17 July 1916 in Artemus, Knox County, Kentucky, the fourth child of John Brogan Linville (11 July 1884 – 15 August 1967) and his second wife, Lucinda (02 December 1891 – 12 March 1963).

John had been previously married to Laura Kinder (18 August 1890 – 15 August 1970), the daughter of Jacob and Katherine Kinder. An announcement in the 02 June 1905 newspaper states “John Linvill [sic] and Laura Kinder, were quietly married at the home of the bride. Rev. John Stamper performing the ceremony.” John was twenty; Laura was fourteen. Other newspapers clippings suggest John met Laura through their church where John was Assistant Secretary of the Sunday school, and Katherine Kinder was first teacher.

John Brogan Linville, 1906, age 21.

John and Lucinda married 09 August 1909.

For almost six decades, when repeatedly asked about Lucinda’s background, Minnie, as well as her entire family, would emphatically state “you do NOT want to know that…” Whatever the secret was, Minnie and her siblings took the secret with them when they passed away. We would joke that they must have been part of the Appalachian Witness Protection Program. The only information we knew was one sentence:  Lucinda was born to a Rose Baker who had five children from five different fathers.

Working backward in the vital records, Lucinda’s death certificate, with information provided by her husband John, indicates her father was “Sam Early” and her mother was “Rose Baker.” A birth record was also located for Lucinda and John’s daughter Mattie Linville (b. 1911) listing Mattie’s mother as Lucinda Early.

More research into the Barbourville area federal censuses and subsequent records indicate there is only one Sam EARLY and one Rosebell BAKER, both living in the Flat Lick Township area.

Samuel Chase Early

Samuel Chase EARLY (26 JUN 1867 – 07 AUG 1909) was the son of Dr. James H. Early (1808-1885) and Rebecca Cummins (1832-1914).

The 1900 Federal Census has a Sam Early with his wife Elon Keele (m. 1898). At the time, the census indicates Sam was a merchant, while newspapers also claim he was a post office inspector and railway mail clerk.

click to enlarge
click to enlarge

In 1901, Sam was involved in a shooting with professor Frank P. Farley in which Farley died.

click to enlarge

Family history is that Lucinda’s husband John Linville was sheriff of Knox County, yet we are unable to locate any evidence. There’s no mention in the censuses, newspapers, or other records. Interestingly, Sam Early ran for sheriff of Knox County in 1904:

click to enlarge
click to enlarge

Included in the newspaper accounts above is an article where have Sam is working or socializing with members of the Baker family.

Sam was murdered on 08 AUG 1909, a day before Lucinda Baker’s marriage to John Linville. He left behind a widow, Elon (Keele) Early, and a 9-month old son, Samuel Coone Early.

click to enlarge

John Henson would later be found guilty in 1910, sentenced to life imprisonment, and then pardoned. The case against William Smith would have a similar outcome:

click to enlarge

Note that the last article describes Sam as a “merchant”, with no reference to past or present duties as sheriff.

Other than the article regarding Sam’s association with Kit Baker, Rosbell’s first cousin, no other smoking gun could be found to corroborate the information in Lucinda Baker’s death certificate.

Rosebell Baker

Rosebell BAKER (24 OCT 1869 – 02 FEB 1955) was the daughter of James Madison Baker (1840-1915) and Melvina Smith (1843-1925). While there are numerous records that support the relationship of Rose to her parents and siblings, the following is the evidence gathered that identifies the children of Rose, and her relationship with Sam Early.

There is no 1900 Federal Census record with any combination or name variation of Rosebell and/or Lucinda.

A 1910 Federal Census has a Vina Baker (widowed), and a Rose, Axie, Cora, and McKinley living next door in West Flat Lick Precinct No. 6. Lucinda does not appear in this household, having married John the prior year.

click to enlarge

And a Rose, McKinley, and Alvina appears in the 1920 Federal Census:

click to enlarge

Using this information, research of the Kentucky School Census has the following information:

1900 School Census of White Children, Flat Lick – New Flat Lick – District #44

PARENT

CHILD (AGE)

BAKER JAMES M

CALHINE BAKER (17)
GROVER C. (16)
WM. (11)
LUCY (9)

Source:  http://www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~kyknox/Census/School-Census/1900-school-census-36-65.html?cj=1&netid=cj&o_xid=0001231185&o_lid=0001231185&o_sch=Affiliate+External

1904 School Census of White Children, White District No. 40 Page 159 

PARENT

CHILD (AGE)

ROSE BAKER

LUCY BAKER (12)
WILLIAM BAKER (15)
EFFIE BAKER (9)
AXIE BAKER (7)

Source:  http://www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~kyknox/Census/School-Census/1904-District-41-60.html?cj=1&netid=cj&o_xid=0001231185&o_lid=0001231185&o_sch=Affiliate+External

Again, no smoking gun connecting Lucinda to Rose.

Shortly after I posted the information above to Ancestry.com, I was contacted through email on 11 October 2017 by Ms. Suzanne Dungan, the great, great granddaughter of Rosebell Baker who confirmed Lucinda’s parents and siblings as follows:

“The Rose Baker with Axie, Cora and McKinley is Lucinda’s mother, and my grandmother’s mom. The line is as follows:

William Baker and Elizabeth Walker

[son of William and Elizabeth] James Madison Baker and Melvina Smith (from Lee Co. Virginia, daughter of William Smith and Elizabeth Edwards)

[daughter of James & Melvina] Rosabel Baker of Flat Lick, Ky.

Children [of Rosabel Baker]:

Lucinda Baker (md. John B. Linville)

Axie Baker md. Mack Jones (lived in Whitley Co. Ky.)

Cora Baker

McKinley Baker (there are at least 2 in Knox Co. and their birthdays are close which is really confusing!) [The other McKinley has a sister Axie which makes it even more confusing!]

I checked with my Mom and asked her if she knew of a Lucinda Baker and/or a John B. Linville. And, of course, she answered, “Yes, Aunt Lucy and Uncle John!”

So, yes! Lucinda Baker Linville was my grandmother’s sister and Rosabell Baker’s daughter. My grandmother was the last child born and Lucinda, Axie, and Cora were all a great deal older than her. So naturally, I wouldn’t have known this information like I would have if my grandmother’s siblings had been closer to her age. Lucinda was at least 20 yrs. older than my grandmother! But, my Mom did know Lucinda and Uncle John and really loved them. Mom stated that Sam Early was Lucinda’s father, but that is all she knows.

I corresponded with Jean Taylor who was the daughter of Axie Baker and Mack Jones. She passed in 2011 and had done some genealogy on her family. She had sent me an email with each child listed and their father’s name. Apparently each one had a different dad.”

After sixty years, our family finally had an answer! Except the answer we received never fully answered why it had remained such a big secret. And that list of all of the fathers? It couldn’t be found. Meanwhile, other descendants of Lucinda’s siblings contacted me as they were also searching for the same answer we had been looking for.

Thus began a search for the fathers of Rosebell’s other children.

To be continued in Part Two

Philip Farmer is currently assisting three families break down their genealogical brick walls and find information on their ancestors. He is also the author and publisher of “Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh,” a 500-page, 155-year biographical history of the Farmer’s immigration from Ireland into Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Virginia, Tennessee, and Harlan County, Kentucky. The continuation of Stephen Farmer’s story from 1800 into the mid-1900’s is currently in work.

Hezekiah Clem: First Man Hanged in Harlan County? [Part 4]

Oral history and numerous retellings of the same story report that Hezekiah Clem was the first person hanged in Harlan County in 1860. What if Hezekiah wasn’t hanged?

In Part 1, we recount who Hezekiah Clem is, his family ties, and his notoriety, and in Part 2 we cover the crime and trial. Part 3 examines the dubious oral history of the hanging.

In addition to the analysis of the oral history covered in Part 3, two vital records also raise suspicion as to whether Hezekiah was hanged in 1860.

First, some background on the Clem family. Hezekiah Hall Clem and Joicy Farmer gave birth to a son Hezekiah Carr Clem in Harlan on 30 October 1858. A marriage bond dated 07 May 1883 has Hezekiah Carr Clem marrying Sarah Wynn. However, a death certificate of 01 May 1938 for a “Sally Clem” has information provided by a “John Clem” of Evarts, Kentucky, presumably her son John Cullen Clem. The information provided states that Sally was born 10 June 1867, the daughter of “W.M. Middleton” and “Susan Turner”, and that her widowed husband is “H.C. Clem”. This information may be incorrect as William Turner Wynn (b.1824, son of Achilles “Acles” Wynn and Lucy Turner) marries in 1848 in Harlan County to a Susannah Turner, born 1833 to James Brittain Turner and Elizabeth Clay. They have a daughter, Sarah. After William’s death, Susannah marries Lorenzo Dow Hall in 1870.

Death Certificate for Sally Clem – Sarah Wynn.

Accepting that “Sarah Wynn” is “Sally Clem”, Hezekiah Carr Clem’s marriage bond has “Kine Clem” as principal, and James B. Howard as surety.

Marriage bond for Alexander C. Clem and Sarah Wynn.

As another nickname for “Hezekiah”, there are three possibilities as to the identity of “Kine”:

  • Hezekiah Carr’s 24-year-old first cousin. His uncle William Clem Jr. (the senior Hezekiah’s brother) married Elizabeth Hall and they also had a son Hezekiah Clem born on 15 October 1859.
  • Hezekiah Carr himself, but it would seem unusual that the bond would identify the same person under two names.
  • Hezekiah Carr’s father, who supposedly hanged in 1860.

The other record that raises suspicion that Hezekiah did not die in 1860 is the death certificate for Joicy’s son Alexander, who along with his brother Lewis (or Louis), has created a very lengthy search to answer this question:  if Hezekiah was hung in 1860, and with Alexander C. Clem[1] born about 1865 and Lewis[2] born about 1867, who are their fathers?

Death certificate for Alexander C. Clem, with magnification of “name of father”.

When Alexander died on 26 December 1929, the informant for his death certification was his son, Martin. The age is given as 64 years old; therefore Alexander was born about 1865, which also coincides with several federal census records. His wife is listed as “Rebecca Clem”, presumably Rebecca Huff who he married on 10 January 1887. His mother is listed as “Josie E. Farmer.”

Depending on interpretation of the handwriting, his father is shown as “Carr” or “Con” Clem. There is no Connor, Conrad, Conway, or other similar named Clem that fits the description for “Con”. A Conway Clem, son of Eva Clem Snowden, is born in 1917. Perhaps Hezekiah lived and adopted “Con” as a shortening of “Convict” to bemuse others? A plausible explanation for Con may be another misheard interpretation and that he was John Clem, brother of Hezekiah. Carr seems more likely; it is a name associated with Hezekiah as previously mentioned in Curtis Burnham Ledford’s oral history, along with other known variations to include Ki, Kiah, Clem, Clemons, Clemens, etc.[3]

Let’s assume Hezekiah died under a tree. Imagine you are his son Alexander growing up in Harlan County. Every year you celebrate another birthday knowing that you were born in 1865. As a child, all of your classmates have heard the stories of your father hanging in 1860 – it may have even been a rhyme while the girls were skipping rope. You and your classmates may have overheard the adults speak of how “Devil Jim” wouldn’t be who he is today if he hadn’t followed “that Hezekiah Clem” fellow. You do the math and realize that Hezekiah couldn’t possibly be your father. As a child you ask your mother Joicy, as well as your other relatives, if the stories are true. What reply do you get?

As you get older and as you go about town, people you meet personally knew Hezekiah, or knew of his actions. Everyone you meet thinks he hung from the gallows. Years later your son Martin is born and grows up with the town gossip. He’s asked, “Aren’t you the grandson of Hezekiah Clem who was hung on Buggar Hollow?” Your son Martin as well as your other children ask you “What happened? Is it true?”

So how do you reply? Do you tell everyone that yes, you are indeed the son of the infamous outlaw? Is that what your mother Joicy told you? Or did she tell you Hezekiah was a husband who died before you were born? If Hezekiah wasn’t your father, do you preserve his memory and proudly claim he was your father?

Now imagine you’re Martin and your father Alexander has just passed away. When completing the death certificate and you’re asked who the father is, what is your reply? If all of the questions above were answered with your grandfather was sentenced, but never hung, and if all of the questions regarding the identity of your father really is Hezekiah, you tell the coroner:  Carr Clem.

So why isn’t Hezekiah in the census if he was still living? It may be that Hezekiah died before the 1870 federal census in which Joicy, Alexander, and Lewis appear. He may have lived past 1870, but we may never know. In a line-by-line search of Harlan County, there’s no 1880 census record for him, Joicy, James, William, Leonard, Hezekiah Carr, Alexander, or Lewis, nor do their names appear in a nationwide search. It’s highly plausible that Hezekiah moved out of Harlan, maybe even out of the country.[4] Years later during the Turner-Howard feuds, newspapers articles recounted how Will Turner killed William Gilbert and left for Texas, George Turner came to Harlan from Texas, several outlaws came in and out from Virginia, Wils[on] Howard repeatedly moved between Harlan and Missouri before he was hung there, and several others escaped into Tennessee. In 1896, a 12-year nationwide hunt for Charles Herndon for the murder of his wife moved him around Tennessee, Georgia, Texas, Mexico, and Oklahoma before he was captured in Colorado. When Governor William Goebel was assassinated in 1900, George Eager moved to New Mexico supposedly with the gun that shot him. Even Devil Jim as “persona non grata” travelled as far west as Toledo, Lewis County, Washington where he died on 05 March 1910.[5]

One other note of interest. Letters from esteemed citizens of Harlan County, including Leonard Farmer, William Clem, William Farmer, and Lewis Farmer, who are relatives of Hezekiah Clem, were sent to the sitting Governor(s) requesting clemency or pardons for various persons.[6] A letter was sent to Beriah Magoffin requesting a pardon of John Pace, charged and sentenced to two years in 1858 for buggery, known today as sodomy and/or bestiality. In April 1861 Francis Pace was convicted of bigamy and sentenced to three years hard labor in the penitentiary. A letter on Francis’ behalf was sent to Governor Bramlett, which coincidentally included the signature of Hezekiah Jennings, Clem’s jailer:

To his Excellency Governor Bramlett,

Frankfort Kentucky

We, the undersigned Petitioners would respectfully inform Your Excellency that at the April Term of the Harlan circuit Court 1861, Francis Pace, a citizen of this county was convicted of the Crime of Bigomy and sentenced to Three years confinement in the Kentucky Penitentiary We, inform Your Excellency that at the time He was convicted He was verry young verry ignorant and verry poore, had but few Friends, had no counsel and in fact, He did not know what plea or what proof was necessary to Acquit him. We further inform Your Excellency that we, believe He was not guilty as charged and that if He had been tried fairley He would not of been convicted, but even should He be guilty we think Two years and Six Month at hard labour is severe a Punishment enought to satisfy the Commonwealth for the crime— We have never seen but one Woman who said she was his wife and if He had any other We think she is satisfied with his absence and denies his being her husband —

We, hope your Excellency will extend to the poor and needy that a Degree of Charaty which is vested in you by the Constitution.

We tharefore Hope and petition your Excellency to pardon the said Pace,

Leonard Farmer
John Jons Jr
William Clem
Lewis Farmer
Hy Jennings (Jailer)
Wm. C. Farmer
Lewis Farmer Jr
Jos. Farmer
Speed Jones
Jno Jones sr.[7]

One could infer that a letter was not required to plead Hezekiah’s case because he had won on appeal. Alternately, one could argue that the wheels of justice moved too quickly from prosecution to execution for a letter to be written. It could also mean that a letter, if it exists, was not published in the collection.

Was Hezekiah Clem hanged? Maybe he was; maybe he wasn’t. Maybe Hezekiah was the Civil War-era Abe Vigoda, reminding everyone that the 1982 reports of his untimely demise was simply a hoax by annually reappearing on late night talk shows until his actual death in 2016. Or in Hezekiah’s circumstances, everyone heard the shocking news that the court house condemned the first man in the county to hang, but neglected to follow up when his case was overturned to less fanfare. Even today with Google at their immediate disposal, people are still victim to the Mandela Effect, remembering things that weren’t really there, or things that weren’t said. Perhaps he was set free and the time spent in the Harlan County jailhouse awaiting the gallows was enough to reform him like his brother-in-law Joseph Nolan. That there is no mention of him beyond 1860 can simply be attributed to a life of normalcy, away from any further crime, and a life not in the public spotlight – no different than any other leaf on a family tree. Aside from interpretations, errors, or omissions in memory or print, perhaps the only way to prove if Hezekiah died on a hot August day in 1860 is through the modern, scientific method of DNA testing. If a male descendant should prove one way or the other through spitting in a tube, the hope is that they inform and educate the rest of us. Genealogists, future family members, and other distant relatives will be forever thankful for it.

One other point of interest:

What about Lewis Clem? Family history is that Lewis’ mother passed away, and when his father was unable to care for him, he was adopted. The story is that his original surname was Livesay, quite possibly a descendant of Joseph Livesay, Sr. At this time, most information gathered is circumstantial evidence with requests for DNA testing of suspected descendants. If you have any supporting information regarding Lewis Clem, or you found a “Lewis” in your Livesay family Bible or records, please contact us by leaving a comment, or completing our contact form, or emailing us at sonsofwhitemarsh@outlook.com.

One July 20, a reader submitted additional evidence regarding Hezekiah Clem. Read the update here.

[1] Alexander’s name varies between sources with middle initial “C” or “Carr”. In the 1900 Federal Census, he is listed as “Alexander R. Clem” with his mother Joicy residing in the household; the middle initial “R” could be a misinterpretation upon incorrectly hearing the middle name of “Carr”. In the 1910 Federal Census, he is listed as “Alec Clem” although it appears an attempt was made to correct the last letter. In the 1920 Federal Census, he is listed as “Alex Clem.” Several forum posts on Ancestry.com in 2000 from “middleton” on the subject states a relationship with “Alexander Bradley Clem” either as a 1g- or a 2g- granddaughter depending on the post(s).

[2] Lewis Clem’s name varies between Lewis or Louis. An Ancestry.com forum post on 02 January 2000 from a “Mary” states her 3g grandfather was “Robert Lewis Clem” married to Mary Jane King.

[3] The Hall family of Harlan County had a “Hezekiah Hall” (1770-1853), Hezekiah Winfield “Carr” Hall (1810-1899), and Hezekiah Winfield “Kike” Hall, Jr. (1849-1937).

[4] A simple, well-worn headstone marks the grave of an “H. Clemens” in Canyon Hill Cemetery in Caldwell, Canyon County, Idaho (Find A Grave Memorial ID#117070848). No birth date, death date, or family relationships are given and a search for his death certificate yields no results. An “He. Clem”, age 27, single, of Athens, Limestone County, Alabama, appears on the 10 June 1861 muster rolls of the Confederate States of America. This record is most likely attributed to Pvt. John Henry Clem born 15 December 1834, son of Vincent Clem and Susan Elizabeth Johnson, who dies 20 January 1908 at the age of 73 and is buried in Pettusville, Limestone County, Alabama. (Find A Grave Memorial ID#22460799). At the end of the Civil War, several Confederate sympathizers moved to Mexico, Central America, and South America, particularly Brazil. Several of them returned to the United States before 1900.

[5] “James Brittain “Devil Jim” Turner”, Geneanet.org. Retrieved 11 April 2018:
https://gw.geneanet.org/ssharonbodet?lang=en&n=turner&oc=0&p=james+brittain+devil+jim

[6] More letters available including the 1858 letter regarding John Pace available via the Civil War Governors of Kentucky:  Digital Documentary Edition, http://discovery.civilwargovernors.org/

[7] “Leonard Farmer et al. to Thomas E. Bramlette”, Civil War Governors of Kentucky:  Digital Documentary Edition. Retrieved 09 April 2018:
http://discovery.civilwargovernors.org/document/KYR-0001-004-0167

Philip Farmer assists families with breaking down their genealogical brick walls. He is currently assisting three families find information on their ancestors. Philip is also the author and publisher of “Edward Farmar and the Sons of Whitemarsh,” a biographical history of Major Jasper Farmar’s family immigration from Ireland to Pennsylvania. Their story continues with their immigration out of Whitemarsh Township into North Carolina, Virginia, and Tennessee, concluding with a biographical sketch of Stephen Farmer who settled in Harlan County, Kentucky. The continuation of Stephen’s story is currently in work.